At a Glance: Thanksgiving Make-Ahead Plan
- Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving: 25 ideas, from sides to pie, in one list.
- Mashed potatoes, soups, cranberry sauce and pies hold up when made a day or two early.
- Turkey, gravy, dressing and rolls are best fresh on Thursday.
Thanksgiving gives you one oven and a long list of dishes that all want it at once. These Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving cover the whole table, and this short guide shows which ones to cook early so Thursday stays calm.
Start with the chart below, then scroll to the full list. A little prep in the days before means less juggling when the guests arrive.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Two Tools That Make Thursday Easier
Most Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving lean on two tools: a good pan and a thermometer. A roast turkey needs a pan that holds the bird up out of its drippings and still fits your oven. Measure your oven’s height before you buy, because a deep pan has to clear the rack above it. This roaster comes with a rack:
- EXTRA LARGE ROASTING PAN WITH RACK: 17-Inch x 13-Inch Nonstick Oven Roaster with Rack
- DURABLE ROASTER RACK: This roaster pan with rack features a convenient U-shaped rack that keeps meats off the bottom of the pan
- FAST AND EVEN HEATING: This turkey roasting pan features heavy duty steel construction for fast, even heat distribution
If you already own a sturdy roasting pan with a rack, skip it.
A thermometer takes the guessing out of the turkey and out of reheated sides. This one reads fast, about half a second by the maker’s claim:
- Ultra-Fast & Highly Accurate: Get precise readings in just 0.5 second with ±0.9°F (±0.5°C) accuracy. The instant read meat...
- Easy to Read: Featuring a large 2.0-inch backlit display, the kitchen thermometer automatically rotates 180° to keep readings upright...
- 100% Waterproof: Easily rinse the professional IP65 waterproof meat thermometer under running water for quick, hassle-free cleanup...
University of New Hampshire Extension says to cook the turkey to 165°F and to check it in three places. Thirteen Tips for Thanksgiving food safety has the full list.
What to Make Ahead and What to Save for Thursday
Your oven is the busiest spot in the kitchen on Thanksgiving, and your fridge has room to spare. Use this chart to sort the Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving into early jobs and Thursday jobs. The last column is a house suggestion, so adjust it to your own menu.

| Dish from the list | When to cook | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Mashed potatoes (#1) and creamy herbed potatoes (#5) | The day before | Reheat them covered, with a splash of milk, until they’re steaming hot all the way through. |
| Carrot and squash curry soup (#7) and pumpkin soup (#8) | The day before | Soups settle in the fridge, and a quick reheat on the stove is all they need. |
| Homemade cranberry sauce (#15) | Two days before | It sets as it chills, so it’s one less pot on Thursday. |
| The three pies (#19 to #21) | The day before | Pies slice cleaner once they’ve chilled overnight. |
| Cornbread dressing (#10) and stuffing (#17) | Thursday | Both are best hot from the oven, baked in their own dish. |
| Turkey (#18) and gravy (#16) | Thursday | Both are best fresh, and the turkey sets the schedule for everything else. |
| No-knead dinner rolls (#9) | Thursday | Rolls are best warm, so bake them while the turkey rests. |
STOP POINT: Get make-ahead dishes into the fridge as soon as they cool, and reheat them until they’re steaming hot all the way through. Illinois Extension says to refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours of cooking, and it’s a good habit for anything you cook ahead too.
CHECKPOINT: With Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving that you cooked ahead, stir each reheated dish and check the center with your thermometer before it goes on the table.
Watch this video from Penn State News and Research, where a Penn State professor shares three tips for a safe Thanksgiving meal:
Pie crust edges brown faster than the filling sets. A shield covers the rim so the crust stays golden while the middle finishes. This one fits 9.5 inch and 10 inch pie plates, so check your plate first:
- Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Protector Shield: covers exposed crust edges during oven baking to help prevent burnt edges and...
- Material And Size: made from aluminum; strong and durable construction; fits 9.5-inch and 10-inch pie plates; measures 11.5 x 11.5 x...
- Even Baking Results: prevents burnt edges, helps lessen edge spillage, and allows pies to rise evenly in the center for perfectly...
Today’s Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving will leave you feeling simply satisfied, nostalgic, and actually excited. Plus, grateful to celebrate this year’s holiday with your family! RELATED: 7 Delicious Pioneer Woman Mac and Cheese Recipes
Pioneer Woman Recipes for an Unforgettable Thanksgiving
1. Delicious Creamy Mashed Potatoes

In my homestead, Thanksgiving is never complete without mouthwatering mashed potatoes. Here’s a rich velvety mashed potato recipe I’m surely trying out this year.
2. Green Beans with Tomatoes

The green and red hues of these green beans with tomatoes will provide a beautiful splash of color on a Thanksgiving plate, so don’t miss this on your Thanksgiving dinner. It’s also so easy, it can be a dinner staple all year long. The best part of the recipe: Bacon!
3. Turnip Gratin

Not into turnips? Think again! Serve this turnip gratin this Thanksgiving and it will change your mind about them. You’ll even wonder why it has not made its way to more Thanksgiving tables all this time.
4. Baked Acorn Squash

As a homesteader, I’m really a squash fanatic. I’m always on the hunt for great ways to prepare a squash dish and this year is no exception. Good thing I found this baked acorn squash; it’s now on top of my list this season. Tell you what, you’ll never regret trying it too.
5. Creamy Herbed Potatoes

Don’t feel like having basic mashed potatoes? Then try this creamy herbed potatoes recipe instead. This will give you a more elegant potato dish that is perfect for a very special occasion.
6. Roasted Carrots

Here’s a Thanksgiving side dish you can easily whip up. With just carrots, a handful of thyme, and some olive oil, you’ll be serving a nutrient-packed dish that will surely hit the spot. Plus, it takes less than an hour to finish up in the oven!
7. Carrot and Squash Curry Soup

Want to start your Thanksgiving dinner with a hearty soup? This carrot and squash curry soup recipe is the perfect one.
8. Pumpkin Soup

If your family isn’t a big fan of carrot and squash soup, why not try this surefire hit pumpkin soup. By the way, it’s fall and a Thanksgiving table is not complete without a pumpkin.
9. No-Knead Dinner Rolls

Complete your dinner with these no-knead dinner rolls. You won’t make rolls the same way again once you taste how totally different this is from your usual store-bought roll.
10. Cornbread Dressing with Sausage and Apple

11. Mini Corn Loaves with Cranberries and Pecans

12. Green Bean Casserole

13. Pumpkin Ravioli

This inventive take promises you’ll never look at ravioli the same way again. This amazingly delicious recipe is the perfect way to use up any leftover pumpkin. No more wasted pumpkin puree ever! RELATED: 14 Homemade Stuffing Recipes For The Perfect Thanksgiving Feast
14. Pot Pie

Brothy, tender, and just delicious! I’m making pot pie this way starting now, to ensure every meal is special with or without a holiday to celebrate.
15. Homemade Cranberry Sauce

Can you imagine a Thanksgiving turkey without cranberry sauce? I can’t! That’s why you should totally check out this homemade cranberry sauce recipe.
16. Turkey Gravy

Your turkey is only as good as your gravy. Here’s an amazing gravy-licious recipe for your Thanksgiving dinner to boost the flavors of your Thanksgiving feast staple for sure.
17. Thanksgiving Dressing/Stuffing

The same goes for your stuffing–what’s a turkey without all the trimmings? Make sure not to overstuff. Just have a slightly firm but very flavorful Thanksgiving dressing/stuffing to have a perfect bird for the whole family to enjoy.
18. Roasted Thanksgiving Turkey

Now, with your gravy and stuffing recipes lined up, it’s time to get that bird done! Get the scrumptious Thanksgiving turkey recipe here and have the ultimate Thanksgiving feast!
19. Pumpkin Cream Pie

This creamy dessert simply defines the taste of fall. If you’re not a fan of pumpkin, then this will be the beginning of it. There’s something about the cream you’ll fall in love with, in this particular pumpkin pie recipe.
20. Pecan Pie

If you’ve been dreading making a pecan pie, this recipe will surely spark some inspiration. The Pioneer Woman has perfected this recipe, and like her, this pie will change your life for the better.
21. Caramel Apple Pie

What’s better than apple pie? Caramel apple pie, of course! The secret ingredient of this recipe? Use Granny Smith apples. Find out why and see the scrumptious difference.
22. Moist Pumpkin Spice Muffins

23. Pear Crisp Vanilla Ice Cream

24. Mulled Apple Cider

Love apple cider? Start making your own with this mulled apple cider recipe, and I bet you won’t rely on store-bought apple cider again.
25. Pumpkin Smoothie

Pumpkin has never been this smooth. With this smoothie recipe, it’s as if you’re sipping a creamy-licious pumpkin pie! Want to see The Pioneer Woman in action? Check out this video where she cooks one of her favorite recipes of all time. Hint: It’s super yummy! We sure hope you’re excited for the big day. Enjoy good food and warm company by some of the best Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving. Now you know how to plan the ultimate Thanksgiving feast with these Pioneer recipes for an unforgettable holiday! What do you think of these Thanksgiving recipes from The Pioneer Woman? Which one will you try? Let me know in the comments below! Up Next:
- Thanksgiving Table Ideas | This Is Everything You Need For A Perfect Thanksgiving Day
- 19 Paleo Recipes to Make This Thanksgiving | Healthy Thanksgiving Ideas
- How To Build A Wooden Swing Set That Your Kids Will Love
Fellow homesteaders, do you want to help others learn from your journey by becoming one of our original contributors? Write for us!
Follow us on Instagram, Twitter, Pinterest, and Facebook!Editor’s Note: This post was originally published on November 8, 2016, and has been updated for quality and relevancy.FAQs
Which Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving can I make ahead?
Mashed potatoes, herbed potatoes, soups, cranberry sauce and the pies all do well when made a day or two early. Chill them promptly, cover them, and reheat until they’re steaming hot all the way through. Save the turkey, the dressing and the rolls for Thursday, since they’re best fresh from the oven.
Do I need to cook all 25 Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving?
No. The list is a menu to pick from. Most tables need one main, a few sides and a dessert or two. Choose the dishes your family already asks for, add one new recipe for fun, and save the rest for another holiday.
Why do make-ahead mashed potatoes get stiff in the fridge?
Cold potatoes firm up as the starch sets. Warm them in a covered dish and stir in a splash of warm milk or a pat of butter until they loosen. Add a little at a time, because it’s easier to thin them than to thicken them again.
How do I fit all of these dishes into one oven?
Move everything you can to the days before, so the oven only has the turkey and a few bakes on Thursday. The turkey needs to rest before carving, and that rest is when the sides get the oven. Bake the rolls last, while the bird sits under foil.
How long can make-ahead dishes sit out, and how long do leftovers last?
Refrigerate cooked food within 2 hours, as university extension guidance says. The University of New Hampshire Extension says leftovers keep for 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. Freeze what you won’t eat in that time, and reheat leftovers until they’re steaming hot all the way through.
Make Ahead or Cook It All on Thursday?
With Pioneer Woman recipes for Thanksgiving, cooking sides early frees the oven and your Thursday. Cooking on the day puts every dish on the table fresh.
Tell us the one dish you’d never make ahead.